Ultra Guard Vs Scotchgard Fabric Protector – What’s the Better Option?

No matter how careful you are, you simply never know when an accident can occur in your home.

And if you have kids and pets, most of those accidents involve staining the carpet, your rugs, your furniture or some article of clothing.

But that’s why fabric protector products exist. Most of them can either prevent stains from setting into fabrics altogether or make them easier to clean out.

However, since stained fabrics are a common problem in America, so too are these kinds of products.

In fact, fabric protector products are so prevalent that it can be very difficult to make a choice from all the options.

So today we are going to be comparing two of the most popular fabric protector brands” Scotchgard and Ultra Guard.

Ultra Guard Overview

Ultra Guard offers a unique in-home service in which one of their technicians will come to your home and apply their nanotech formula.

Ultra Guard in-home service is available all over the country.

The company states that their fabric protector permanently bonds with the fiber of your fabric to offer lifetime protection from stains. In fact, they offer a lifetime guarantee on their professional applications.

However, they do sell some do-it-yourself products in the form of spray-on fabric protectors. They don’t make a lot of direct to consumer products as of yet compared to a company like Scotchgard – and speaking of Scotchgard…

Scotchgard Overview


The Scotchgard brand has been around for a very long time and they make a wide variety of spray-on fabric protectors.

They are a subsidiary of the 3M corporation. The Scotchard brand hit the shelves all the way back in 1956.

What’s the Difference Between Ultra Guard and Scotchgard?

The main difference between the two brands is that Scotchgard does not have any in-home service.

All of their products are meant to be sold directly to, and used by the consumer. Ultra Guard offers a service and a product.

Another difference is that with the Ultra Guard service, your fabrics are guaranteed for a lifetime whereas with Scotchgard, you have to reapply every so often.

Quick Facts

Ultra Guard






In-home fabric protector application

Fabric, stain and water protection products


Spray-on fabric protectors and stain removers

Spray-on fabric protectors, stain removers and in-home application services


Online and in stores


Ultra Guard Products

Ultra-Guard’s Stain Free Fabric Protection

Selling Points:

  • Non-toxic
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Anti-microbial

The great thing about this product is that it offers professional-level protection for all your fabrics. This is for anyone who wants to protect their car upholstery, furniture, rugs, patio furniture, bedding carpet and more.

The application dries in 6-8 hours and it won’t leave a texture on your fabrics. It also won’t discolor your fabrics. Best of all it protects against all kinds of stains and inhibits the growth of mold and mildew.

Overall Score: 98/100

Check Out More Reviews Here:


Ultra Guard’s Easy Does it Stain Remover

Selling Points:

  • Deodorizes
  • Professional grade
  • Easy spray bottle

The Easy Does it stain remover is for anyone who regularly deals with heavy-duty stains like candle wax, latex paint, crayon and even blood.

This is a professional grade stain remover and what we really liked about it was that it works almost instantly.

And if you have pets, you’ll be very interested to know that not only does it remove pet stains; but it also helps remove the odor of pet stains.

Overall Score: 97/100

Check Out More Reviews Here:


Scotchgard Products

Scotchgard OXY Spot & Stain Remover for Pets

Selling Points:

  • Penetrates down to the carpet padding
  • Good for other stains
  • Protects against future stains

The Scotchgard OXY Spot & Stain Remover for Pets would be an excellent choice if you have one or more indoor pets. What we liked about  this spray-on cleaner was that it starts to lift the stain immediately.

You have to dab the stain out by hand; but at least you don’t have to wait a long time for the remover to start working. Plus, it can be used for non-pet stains like mud, wine and food stains.

Overall Score: 95/100

Check Out More Reviews Here:


Scotchgard Fabric Crafts Water Shield

Selling Points:

  • Made for delicate fabrics
  • Odorless
  • Retains fabric breathability

The Scotchgard Fabric Crafts Water Shield will be great for anyone who wants to protect more delicate fabrics like silk, wreaths, wool and needlepoint crafts.

We like that it doesn’t leave behind any visible film or odor so the look of your crafts aren’t altered.

The point of this product is to repel water off of your delicate fabrics to protect from staining and to make them easier to clean.

Overall Score: 94/100

Check Out More Reviews Here:


Scotchgard Fabric & Carpet Cleaner

Selling Points:

  • Blocks future stains
  • Penetrates deep into fibers
  • Works on all kinds of fabrics

This may be one of Scotchgard’s most versatile products. We like it because it can be used on curtains, luggage, table linens, bedding, rugs, carpets, backpacks and much more.

It won’t truly block harsh stains but it makes them much easier to clean. The soil is moved up to the surface so all you have to do is blot it away with a colorfast cloth or rag.

Overall Score: 96/100

Check Out More Reviews Here:


Honorable Scotchgard Product Mentions

  • Scotchgard Rug & Carpet Protector
  • Scotchgard Fabric Water Shield
  • Scotchgard OXY Spot & Stain Remover for Carpet & Fabric

What is the Difference Between Scotchgard Fabric Protector and Water Shield?

The Water Shield can only protect against water-based stains while the Fabric Protector protects against a broader range of non water-based stains.

Who Has the Better Product Range?

Scotchgard certainly has the wider product range while Ultra Guard focuses only on a couple different products.

Which Brand Has the Safer Products?

There was some controversy surrounding Scotchgard some time ago about their products not being safe for the environment.

While Ultra Guard products are made to be safe, Scotchgard has also changed their formula to be more eco-friendly.

Did Scotchgard Get Discontinued?

No, their products were never discontinued.

Is Ultra Guard Fabric Protector Toxic?

No, Ultra Guard products are non-toxic, hypoallergenic and eco-friendly.

Which is the Best Company?

It’s hard to compare because Ultra Guard offers a fabric protection service in addition to products.

If you prefer to have a professional come to your home or business to apply fabric protector, Ultra Guard is the best company. If however, you prefer to handle the application yourself, Scotchgard is the brand for you.

It is also worth mentioning that when you opt for in-home service from Ultra guard, you get a lifetime guarantee. Scotchgard doesn’t offer a similar guarantee.

  • Scotchgard Overall Rating: 96/100
  • Ultra Guard Overall Rating: 97/100

Final Assessment

Ultra Guard is a unique company that offers a standout service – and a professional one to boot. Scotchgard offers more products and has been around for longer than Ultra Guard.

Ultimately, the answer to the question, “what’s the better option” will depend on your specific needs and preferences.

Busy people looking for the utmost protection may be more inclined toward Ultra Guard while people who may not expect to keep their current furniture or carpeting long-term might prefer Scotchgard.

Both brands offer unique advantages so carefully assess your needs and take a look at their products!